Monday, February 2, 2009

Research Report Critique..

A) Book 31E: “Asian American Supermarket Directory” By: Kacky Keomany

  1. Statement of the Problem: Residents not being able to locate the nearest Asian/ Asian-American Supermarkets within their cities in the Bay Area due to the minimal amount of printed information.
  1. Procedure: Main procedures for data collection were to survey people and also do fieldwork to collect as much information about the problem. Surveying local residents worked and what didn’t work that well was time management to interviewing more resources, such as supermarket owners, because of their availability. Chapter 2 was well organized and presented because of all the research presented and diagrams to show for the research that was done leading to the hypothesis.
  1. Hypothesis: The hypothesis was formulated by designing a “creative” and “cost-effective” pamphlet for local residents with Asian/Asian-American Supermarket location and contact information (directory). The hypothesis was clearly stated and was tested by actually distributing prototype directory pamphlets throughout Bay Area cities.
  1. Major Findings: Most of Chapter 3 was information of the hypothesis and the outcome of the experiment. Also contained main information on the design of the pamphlets with images of the actual printed design. The overall information relates to the hypothesis because it was the data collected. It was logically organized, solutions were clear because of the visuals, and easy to follow.
  1. Conclusions: The research concluded to be a success, not only because this purpose was new but also because of the positive feedback from all the research that was completed. The data collected and findings presented are all in order.
  1. Appendix Materials: The materials organized into appendices are all information related to the report. I didn’t really understand two of the charts but looking at it shows it had something to do with time used for the project. The rest of the material was clear and related.
  1. Overall Critique: The strong points of the research report were the surveys that were done and the fieldwork used to collect more data. There weren’t any weak points to me because all the research done was to the point and necessary to complete the project except for one little section. There were photos and diagrams included. The only thing that was slightly off was the shutter speed for the camera information. It makes sense why it’s there to begin with but it was unnecessary. This report is worth reviewing for other students because it was a purpose that was never really done before and all the fieldwork and information were straight to the point on solving the purpose.

B) Book 31F: “An Examination of Materials to be used for the Design and Development of a Restaurant Website” By: Peter Lee

  1. Statement of the Problem: Chinese Restaurant Industry is highly competitive because there are so many, one specific restaurant in Sunnyvale, CA is finding out solutions to gain more customers.
  1. Procedure: By discussing with the client about marketing strategies and what their main goals/ideas for the restaurant was. Also doing research on the internet for web designers and extra data. The procedure for this project worked because it was focused on creating a website for a local restaurant to get more publicity to attract more customers. Chapter 2 was well organized because it started off with a brief history leading to the marketing aspects.
  1. Hypothesis: To create a website and market it on the internet including promotional deals, menu, contact information, etc. The hypothesis was clearly stated and to be executed by creating a website for the client.
  1. Major Findings: Chapter 3 was developed by the main focus of creating a website. There were sketches of ideas, a flow chart of what will be on the website, and all other information needed for design including navigation and color. Surveys were also given to customers of the restaurant to gain feedback for improvements for better advertisement.
  1. Conclusions: The research concluded that having a website is beneficial to the client and the customers. The conclusion relates to all data collected and findings presented because it was focused on how to create a website to expand business.
  1. Appendix Materials: All the materials were organized into appendices and were easy to follow. All materials relate to the report and are clear because it shows preliminary and final work.
  1. Overall Critique: The strong points of this research project were the discussions between the student and client and surveys conducted for feedback to benefit the restaurant. The weak point of this research was it was too easy and not as interesting because designing a website to expand business is so typical. Especially to promote an impacted industry to one of the most common ways of marketing. A different hypothesis would have been better to help commercialize the restaurant more. Since the business was under new management, they could have gone towards a different direction such as creating a more unique logo for the restaurant because signage catches the eye. This report to me is an example of completing this project the easy way.

C) Online: “Youth Credit Union Program” By: Valdemar I. Duran

  1. Statement of the Problem: The Youth Credit Union Program (YCUP) don’t have enough outreach materials to attract more low-income youth (ages 18 and under) to their program.
  1. Procedure: Coming up with ideas to best advertise towards the audience ages 18 and under by using certain messages, images, and color schemes to attract them to YCUP. Researching different advertisement through media such as city bus cards, etc. Surveying people. Chapter 2 was well organized because it went over on how to begin the research also including personal interview answers and questions related to the project.
  1. Hypothesis: To design outreach material that would have the most effect on low-income urban youth to attract them to YCUP to teach the youth how to manage money through a positive aspect.
  1. Major Findings: The main idea was coming up with various ideas by designing eye-catching posters. Color schemes, fonts, distorting actual photos of the youth in the city, and interviews. Chapter 3 was clearly presented and represented the hypothesis and the solution.
  1. Conclusions: The research concluded that not much attention is given to those who have low-income, or lack financially which is unfair. Yet starting with posters to reach out to the youth is just a start. The conclusion could be stated better by including more about the design aspect of the research project and positive outcome from it instead of pity.
  1. Appendix Materials: The appendix was organized but could have flowed better in the panel of experts because the first page stood out while the rest of the pages for the panel of experts didn’t. Leaves you a bit confused when reading online. Other than that it flowed very well and made sense with the whole project.
  1. Overall Critique: The subject alone was a strong point to this research, but the ideas of all the posters to catch the eye of the audience was very nice. The photos used for poster ideas were another strong point. The overall hypothesis, to come up with ideas to create an eye-catching poster to attract youth to the YCUP, was a great idea and all the information focused on what design concepts to use for the specific audience all fit in with the project. I would recommend this project to other students just from the creativity of the poster ideas alone.

No comments:

Post a Comment